January 20, 2004

Seabiscuit (2003, Gary Ross) 28

Show, I guess. A shockingly flabby follow-up to Pleasantville; where Pleasantville was (whatever else you might think about it) narratively tight, this thing lumbers through forty minutes of beginnings before starting where it should, with Jeff Bridges meeting Chris Cooper. Until that point, we have to suffer through a tiring succession of "dramatic" events that are supposed to tell us "who these characters are" and what's "at stake for them", and failing at each of these tasks. Ever taken a writing class where, as an exercise, the class creates a character, and throws a bunch of life story on the blackboard? Well, here's what it looks like when it's filmed. Screenwriters, do me a favor: cut this backstory shit out of the first draft, or incorporate it into the story in a way that doesn't slow it down. You're killin' me.

Once it starts, though, it's enjoyable enough, if unremarkable. I mean, sure, I can sympathize with a character who likes to sleep all day and eat twice as much as anyone else; who can't? But don't tell me this horse was more important than the New Deal. Director, please.

Finally, call me cynical or just over-sensitive, but I can't help but feel queasy when a rich character completely unaffected by the depression gives a series of bullshit press conferences and the reporters nod furiously and jot down every word like it was gospel. Guess I'm just funny like that.

Where we saw it: dvd | We deign to rate it: outta 100
Posted by kza at 01:47 PM | Comments (3)
Comments

I was surprised to see this get nods at the Golden Globes, and now the Oscars. I haven't seen it yet, but from everything I've heard it's not a great movie. Maybe GOOD, but not great. It seems there were much better movies that could have made the short list. I had the same feeling about Cold Mountain being on the Golden Globes list, but I was glad to see that it didn't make the Oscars.

Posted by: martin at January 27, 2004 09:27 AM

Dammit, the Oscars! I totally forgot about them! I usually get up early in the morning and watch the announcements, cuz I'm a geek, but I blew it.

Guess I need to see City of God now. Damn.

Yay for Johnny Depp!

Posted by: Kza at January 27, 2004 11:11 AM

Have you seen a copy of City of God anywhere? I've been trying to find it! It's not playing anywhere, and I can't find a DVD.

Posted by: martin at January 27, 2004 11:29 AM